A season-by-season jump page for the historical NFL picks, score projections, and weekly game analysis from the archive years.
| Season | Record | ATS | Archive |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 242-30 (88.9%) | Not available | Season results pending archive recovery |
| 2020 | Not available | Not available | Open 2020 archive |
| 2017 | Not available | Not available | Open 2017 archive |
| 2016 | 166-89 (65.10%) | 151-105 (58.98%) | Open 2016 archive |
| 2015 | 162-94 (63.28%) | 151-105 (58.98%) | Open 2015 archive |
| 2014 | 83-48 (63.36%) | 63-70 (47.37%) | Open 2014 archive |
| 2013 | 164-93 (63.81%) | 136-121 (52.92%) | Open 2013 archive |
| 2012 | 160-97 (62%) | 139-116 (55%) | Open 2012 archive |
| 2011 | 176 winners (68%) | Not available | Open 2011 archive |
| 2010 | Not available | Preseason: 86% | Open 2010 archive |
| 2009 | 175-77 (69%) | Not available | Open 2009 archive |
| 2008 | 159-91 (64%) | Not available | Open 2008 archive |
| 2007 | 160-96 (63%) | Not available | Open 2007 archive |
| 2006 | 163-93 (64%) | Not available | Open 2006 archive |
| 2005 | 167-88 (65%) | Not available | Open 2005 archive |
| 2004 | 162-94 (63%) | Not available | Open 2004 archive |
| 2003 | 169-87 (66%) | Not available | Open 2003 archive |
| 2002 | 156-100 (61%) | Not available | Open 2002 archive |
| 2001 | 153-94 (62%) | Not available | Open 2001 archive |
| 2000 | 132-82 (62%) | Not available | Open 2000 archive |